Gathatoulie

And of these shall I speak to those eager, That quality of wisdom that all the wise wish And call creative qualities And good creation of the mind The all-powerful truth Truly and that more & better ways are discovered Towards perfection --Zarathustra.

Thursday, October 15, 2009

scientific theories?

"Scientific theories seem to be a-causal chiefly only in so far as they are
formulated in explicit formal and mathematical terms." -- Gopnik and Glymour

Is that really true? It strikes me as odd that formalism and
math would pull us away from causal thinking.

2 comments:

Martin Owens said...

hmm, he might be trying to get at the idea that scientific theorising tends to require seperation which kills systematic thinking.

Think about the story of a child who wants to grow up as a biologist. She goes to a field and picks some flows and attempts to learn how they grow.

She is sad that they all die.

arided said...

The sheer poetry of this is disarming.

I think you're right; and I guess the point
I'm taking away from this is that there
is a difference between "science",
which includes causal models, and
"causal thinking", which is a form of
thinking.

Science isn't thinking.

Post a Comment

Post a Comment

Blog Archive

words cut, pasted, and otherwise munged by joe corneli otherwise known as arided.